Showing posts with label ICANN60. Show all posts
Showing posts with label ICANN60. Show all posts

2017-11-12

News Review | Warning To dotBRANDS & Moment of Truth at ICANN60

graphic "News Review" ©2016 DomainMondo.com
Domain Mondo's weekly internet domain news review (NR 2017-11-12) with analysis and opinion: Features •  1) Warning To dotBRANDS & Moment of Truth at ICANN60, 2) Other ICANN news: a. SSR2-RT Status Report, b. Emoji in Domains, c. New gTLDs Collisions, and more, 3) Names, Domains & Trademarks: Trademark King, Domain Registration in China, Verisign at Techweek Los Angeles, David Redl in at NTIA.doc.gov, Trump Domains Hijacked, and more, 4) ICYMI Internet Domain News, 5) Most Read Posts.

1) a. Warning to dotBRANDS at ICANN60: 
Brand Registry Group Update (pdf) dotBrand Trends and Use Cases, Thursday, 2 Nov 2017:
graphic "dotBrands - ICANN New gTLD 2012 Application Round"
graphic "dotBrands Operational Concerns - Universal Acceptance - email - UASG"
Editor's Note - Translation: that fancy dotBRAND new gTLD (for which you paid ICANN $185,000 upfront), will likely not work as expected on the internet, including in email applications. For more info: News Review: ICANN's Extortionate .BRAND Scam Failing.

1) b. Moment of Truth at ICANN60: 
GNSO - NCSG Meeting 31 October 2017 re: Consumer Safeguards (video beginning at 2:20:00):

Question to ICANN's Consumer Safeguards Director Bryan SchillingWhat are the protections that are in place for [domain name] registrants?
screenshot of ICANN's Consumer Safeguards Director Bryan Schilling at ICANN60
Schilling's answer: "I don’t know, I can get back to you on that."

[Editor's note: #Clueless]

2) Other ICANN news
graphic "ICANN | Internet Corporation for Assigned Names and Numbers"
a. SSR2 Review Team Work STATUS Report 11 Nov 2017: Work SUSPENDED (pursuant to directive of ICANN Board of Directors, 28 Oct 2017, accepted by ICANN AC/SOs (pdf). Restart date TBD, latest correspondence.

b. Use of Emoji in Domain Names--Approved Board Resolutions | Regular Meeting of the ICANN Board 2 Nov 2017 | ICANN.org: "... Whereas, the SSAC report concluded that emoji should not be included in TLD labels and strongly discouraged the registration of any domain name that includes emoji in any of its labels ... Resolved (2017.11.02.09), the Board hereby directs that conformance to IDNA2008 and its successor will continue to be a necessary condition to determine valid IDN TLD labels. Resolved (2017.11.02.10), the Board requests that the Country Code Names Supporting Organization (ccNSO) and the Generic Names Supporting Organization (GNSO) engage with the SSAC to more fully understand the risks and consequences of using a domain name that includes emoji in any of its labels, and inform their respective communities about these risks. Resolved (2017.11.02.11), the Board requests that the ccNSO and GNSO integrate conformance with IDNA2008 and its successor into their relevant policies so as to safeguard security, stability, resiliency and interoperability of domain names."  [Editor's Note: A cynic might say "Oh, go ahead and use the emojis, after all, ICANN delegated over 1200 new gTLDs into the root KNOWING most would FAIL TO WORK as expected on the internet--what's a few more defective gTLDs?"]

c. New gTLDs & Domain Name Collisions--Approved Board Resolutions | Regular Meeting of the ICANN Board 2 Nov 2017 | ICANN.org--"the Board has considered the applications for .CORP, .HOME and .MAIL and determined to defer delegation of these names indefinitely because of collisions. [Editor's note: good idea. Too bad the ICANN Board 2012-2014 wasn't as careful about new gTLDs "failing to work as expected on the internet" which ICANN had known about since at least 2003!]  A name collision occurs when an attempt to resolve a name used in a private name space (e.g. under a non-delegated Top-Level Domain, or a short, unqualified name) results in a query to the public Domain Name System (DNS). When the administrative boundaries of private and public namespaces overlap, name resolution may yield unintended or harmful results. This class of as-yet undelegated strings is referred to as “Collision Strings.” In some cases, the unintended or harmful results of delegating Collision Strings may be considered “high-risk” ... the Board is ... requesting that the SSAC conduct a thorough study and provide advice to the Board regarding the risks posed to users and end systems if .CORP, .HOME, .MAIL strings were to be delegated in the root." See also: IDN Relevant Board Resolutions | ICANN.org.

d. Office of the Chief Technology Officer Document Archive | ICANN.org: Update on Postponing the Root KSK Roll.

e. ICYMI: New gTLD .WEB Appeal by Ruby Glen (Donuts), ICANN's Answering Brief --Editor's note: a "must read" if you want to know what is really going on re: .WEB and how Donuts, like many other new gTLD applicants, has probably made most of its money thus far with ICANN's new gTLDs (hint: gaming in the private new gTLD auctions), with analysis you will not find anywhere else on the web).

f. ICANN61 | San Juan Updates
graphic: "ICANN61 | San Juan" ©2017 DomainMondo.com
3) Names, Domains & Trademarks
graphic "Names, Domains & Trademarks" ©2017 DomainMondo.com
•  Trademark King? Thousands more trademarks linked to Michael Gleissner unearthed; leading in-house lawyer calls for action | WorldTrademarkReview.com"Nearly 2,000 additional applications seemingly linked to entrepreneur revealed, some appear to be for terms associated with established, well-known brands. Leading in-house lawyer calls on IP bodies to do more and offer guidance."

• Domain Name Registration in China: An updated (Aug 2017) regulation, adopted by the Ministry of Industry and Information Technology, requires registrars to verify the accuracy of information submitted by registrants. Registrars must not share the information with third parties without consent from the registrants who are also required to register any changes to their identity and contact info within 30 days--Xinhuanet.com.

• Verisign at Techweek Los Angeles (techweek.com/losangeles), Thursday, Nov 16 • 12:10-12:40pm, at The Broad Stage 1310 11th St, Santa Monica, CA 90401: "Building Your Online Presence hosted by Verisign: Join Ebrahim Keshavarz, Verisign SVP of Product Management and one of the top minds behind Verisign.com’s innovative names suggestion service and Alexandra Watkins, Brand Name Expert (domain: eatmywords.com) and Author, for a fireside chat as they discuss how this useful tool can help you find the perfect domain name to build your brand online and grow your business(emphasis and links added).

•  NTIA.doc.gov: David Redl, President Trump’s nominee to head the National Telecommunications and Information Administration (NTIA), was approved by the Senate on Nov 7, 2017--TheHill.com.

• Trump Domains Hijacked: According to security experts, hackers hijacked the web addresses by penetrating and altering domain registration records at registrar GoDaddy.com--news-herald.com.

•  KF.org UDRP Claimant John S. and James L. Knight Foundation, Inc., DENIED Relief: "Complainant has acknowledged Respondent’s rights and legitimate interests in the domain name through its offer to purchase the name for $20,000."--adrforum.com

• Bad actors on the web are now using a combination of Google search-engine optimization (SEO) for banking-related keywords, compromised websites that rank high in Google Search results, and malicious Word macros to infect users with the Zeus Panda bank credential stealer.--ZDNet.com and Poisoning the Well: Banking Trojan Targets Google Search Results | Talos Group at Cisco | talosintelligence.com.

• The Dark Web"... the deep web makes up most of the internet ... [m]uch of the content here is only available through the intranet — a private network — and includes things like medical and financial records, content from academic databases and government resources. Further below, under the cover of encrypted technology, lies the dark web. Google does not index the dark web ... How do you access the dark web? ... It can only be accessed through a program called Tor, which stands for The Onion Router. On Tor, the sites have a .ONION domain name ..."--KSL.com.

•  Sci-Hub blocked by Court Order: Internet search engines, web hosting sites, internet service providers (ISPs), domain name registrars and domain name registries ordered to cease facilitating “any or all domain names and websites through which Defendant Sci-Hub engages in unlawful access to, use, reproduction, and distribution of the ACS Marks or ACS's Copyrighted Works.” --ScienceMag.org.

•  [gnso-rpm-wg] Change in Status | mm.icann.org"Dear WG Members: I have today, November 6, 2017, terminated all operations of the Virtualaw LLC consultancy and commenced employment in the legal department of Verisign, Inc. in the position of Policy Counsel. I intend to continue in my co-chair position, and will update my SOI prior to our next call."--Philip S. Corwin.

4) ICYMI Internet Domain News: 
graphic "ICYMI Internet Domain News" ©2017 DomainMondo.com
•  United Arab Emirates: Seven Months After Completing His Sentence, Blogger Osama Al-Najjar Remains in Prison | GlobalVoices.org.

•  Data, Privacy, & Liability: Data Breaches and Damages--Equifax Discloses its Coming Nightmares | WolfStreet.com Nov 10, 2017.

• Internet Association Endorses Internet Censorship Bill | Electronic Frontier Foundation | EFF.org"... Just a few hours after Senator Thune’s amended version of SESTA surfaced online, the Internet Association rushed to praise the bill’s sponsors for their “careful work and bipartisan collaboration.” The compromise bill has all of the same fundamental flaws as the original. Like the original, it does nothing to fight sex traffickers, but it would silence legitimate speech online ..." See also Why Google and Facebook folded on sex-trafficking bill--"the first major legislative defeat for tech giants Google and Facebook"--Axios.com.

•  China’s Severe Curbs on the Internet Leave Little to Censor | Bloomberg.comPresident Xi Jinping is the "first Chinese leader to truly understand the power of the internet, and hence we are seeing an unprecedented crackdown on dissenting information.”

• Federal move to undo internet freedom would make US more like Russia, not less | TheHill.com: "... According to the bill’s own legislative findings and its sponsors’ remarks, more than $1.4 billion was spent on online political advertising last year. Of that amount, some $100,000 (less than 0.01 percent) has been reported thus far as coming from Russian interests. But S.1989 fails at even a perfunctory attempt to target foreign interference. Instead, the bill would almost entirely regulate Americans ..." See also New York Times' Assault on Press Freedom"The New York Times, which once postured as the champion of a free press, now is seeking crackdowns on news that the public gets from the Internet under the guise of combating “Russian propaganda”--Consortiumnews.com.

 FCC Chairman Ajit Pai's Rollback of 'Open Internet Order' at Risk in States | USnews.com"The FCC chairman shouldn't allow states to undermine the rollback of Title II regulations ... Simply put, the U.S. is an attractive market with a common language, common currency and common regulatory policy supporting private infrastructure investment, including wireless and wireline networks delivering internet connection. This is not the case in the European Union, where innovators have to contend with 28 nations, 24 languages and 17 currencies ..."

•  How Level 3's Tiny Error Shut Off the Internet for Parts of the U.S. | WIRED.com.

•  André Staltz: The Web began dying in 2014, here's how | staltz.com

5) Top 3 Most Read Posts this past week on DomainMondo.com: 
graphic "Domain Mondo" ©2017 DomainMondo.com
1. News Review | ICANN60: ICANN Board Crashes The Party in Abu Dhabi
2. New gTLD .WEB Appeal by Ruby Glen (Donuts), ICANN's Answering Brief
3. Tech Review | Russia, Tech, & Elections: We Have Met The Enemy, She Is
-- John Poole, Editor, Domain Mondo 

feedback & comments via twitter @DomainMondo


DISCLAIMER

2017-11-05

News Review | ICANN60: ICANN Board Crashes The Party in Abu Dhabi

News Review | ©2016 DomainMondo.com
Domain Mondo's weekly internet domain news review (NR 2017-11-05) with analysis and opinion: Features •  1) ICANN60: ICANN Board Crashes The Party in Abu Dhabi, 2) Other ICANN news, 3) Names, Domains & Trademarks: ICANN, Registrars, Registries--Don't Be Censors! 4) ICYMI, 5) Most Read Posts.
1) ICANN60 Recap: ICANN Board Crashes The Party in Abu Dhabi
 a. ICANN Board Suspends SSR2 Review Team Work on October 28:

ICANN Meeting 60 - GNSO Working Session: (10/29/2017 02:55): Keith Drazek (RySG): "The scope of the SSR2-RT is pretty clearly detailed in the new, post-transition ICANN bylaws."... GNSO Chair James Bladel: "it's an open question whether the ICANN Board can pause the work of the SSR2-RT" ... Wolf Ulrich"nobody understands what the Board's problem with the SSR2-RT is" ... Michele Neylon"it would be helpful to get clarity" ... Chat (10/29/2017 03:00) --Keith Drazek (RySG): For additional context, prior to the IANA Transition, the Review Team members were appointed by the ICANN CEO and GAC Chair. Post-transition, the SOs and ACs are responsible for the appointment of RT members. Also, if I'm not mistaken, the SSR2-RT recommendations are binding  and the Board is obligated to accept them.  It appears there's some discomfort with these parameters. Susan Kawaguchi: Can we deny the request?  and move on?
ICANN GNSO Council Meeting, 1 Nov 2017(pdf): "Okay. Then let's move on to Agenda Item Number 5 ... Agenda Item Number 5 is a discussion on the SSR2 review team, which if you had told me a week ago that I would have been speaking more about SSR2 than GDPR, I would have probably laughed at you. But that's exactly how it went down this week."--GNSO Council Chair James Bladel.
Editor's note: Out of the gate, ICANN's Board of Directors, on the first day of ICANN60, Oct 28, took the unprecedented and questionable action of suspending the work of the Security, Stability, and Resiliency Review Team appointed by ICANN AC/SOs' Chairs as mandated by ICANN's bylaws Article 4. Section 4.6, and it became the lingering lead issue of ICANN60 throughout the entire meeting, including the last day, notwithstanding pending pressing issues of complying with EU's GDPR by next May, next steps in dealing with the contentious issue of new gTLD .AMAZON, ICANN's U.S. jurisdiction and the implications of OFAC brought up in the course of Accountability WS-2's work, and a myriad of other issues expected by stakeholders to be the focus of their work this past week at ICANN60.

On the last day, Friday, Nov 3, 2017, the beleaguered SSR2 Review Team, still in Abu Dhabi after almost everyone else had flown the coop, held its previously scheduled all-day face-to-face meeting with little more to do than "review feedback" from ICANN60 sessions, and then begin putting back the pieces the ICANN Board had left strewn about Abu Dhabi. For more read ICANN60, Abu Dhabi, ICANN Board Suspends SSR2 Work and Statement from SO/AC Chairs, Nov 2, 2017, on the suspension of the Security and Stability Review.

b. Governmental Advisory Committee (GAC) Communique (pdf): The GAC elected Manal Ismail (Egypt) as Chair to complete the two-year term of Thomas Schneider. The GAC elected as Vice Chairs: Guo Feng (China); Ghislain de Salins (France); Milagros Castañon (Peru); Chérif Diallo (Senegal); Pär Brumark (Niue). The GAC discussed follow-up on previous advice re: 1. Application for .amazon and related strings; 2. 2-Character Country Codes at the 2nd Level;  3. Red Cross and Red Crescent Protections. Several GAC members "expressed major concerns regarding the draft report from the sub-group on jurisdiction. These members consider that it falls short of the objectives envisaged for Work Stream 2, and that its recommendations only partly mitigate the risks associated with ICANN’s subjection to US jurisdiction, which makes the adoption of the report unacceptable" (emphasis added). GAC Consensus Advice to the Board: 1. Intergovernmental Organization (IGO) Protections; 2. Enabling inclusive, informed and meaningful participation in ICANN; 3. GDPR / WHOIS; 4. Applications for .amazon and related strings--a. The GAC advises the ICANN Board to: i. continue facilitating negotiations between the Amazon Cooperation Treaty Organization’s (ACTO) member states and the Amazon corporation with a view to reaching a mutually acceptable solution to allow for the use of .amazon as a top level domain name.

c. GDPR & WHOISData Protection/Privacy Issues | ICANN.org.

d. WS2-Accountability: see Co-Chairs Statement from CCWG-Accountability Meeting in Abu Dhabi | ICANN.org and ICANN Jurisdiction: CCWG-Accountability WS2, Friday Oct 27, Abu Dhabi.

e. Public Forum #2--Domain name registrant's complaint about new TLDs that "don't work" on the internet--Public Forum excerpts (as transcribed unedited, emphasis added)(pdf):

f. Public ICANN Board Meeting (Editor's note: see tweet below on why all ICANN Board Meetings should be public and accessible online):

g. Competition, Consumer Trust and Consumer Choice Review (CCT)

ICANN60 Interview With Jonathan Zuck and Drew Bagley: progress and next steps of the Competition, Consumer Trust, and Consumer Choice Review from CCT Chair Jonathan Zuck and CCT Independent Expert Drew Bagley of securedomain.org. In this interview produced by ICANN, Zuck and Bagley share information about the CCT Review, including next steps. More information at ICANN.org.

2) Other ICANN news
.AMAZONApproved Board Resolutions | Request for New or Additional Information from the Governmental Advisory Committee (GAC) re: Advice on Amazon Applications | ICANN.org 29 Oct 2017: Whereas, the BAMC has recommended ... Resolved (2017.10.29.02), the Board asks the GAC if it has: (i) any information to provide to the Board as it relates to the "merits-based public policy reasons," regarding the GAC's advice that the Amazon applications should not proceed; or (ii) any other new or additional information to provide to the Board regarding the GAC's advice that the Amazon applications should not proceed. Resolved (2017.10.29.03), the Board asks the GAC that if it has any new or additional information (as requested above) to provide to the Board, it does so by the conclusion of the ICANN61 meeting scheduled to take place from 10-15 March 2018, in order to assist the Board's appropriate and prompt consideration.

Data Protection/Privacy Statement--Statement from ICANN Contractual Compliance | ICANN.org: "As discussed at ICANN60, the extent of the impact of the GDPR on WHOIS and other contractual requirements related to domain name registration data is uncertain. The ICANN Board, org and community are engaged in multiple efforts to assess the impact of the GDPR on registry and registrar obligations in ICANN agreements and policies, and we continue to work with the Hamilton law firm to understand this impact. At this point, we know that the GDPR will have an impact on open, publicly available WHOIS ... During this period of uncertainty, and under the conditions noted below, ICANN Contractual Compliance will defer taking action against any registry or registrar for noncompliance with contractual obligations related to the handling of registration data. To be eligible, a contracted party that intends to deviate from its existing obligations must share its model with ICANN Contractual Compliance and the Global Domains Division." (emphasis added)

Approved Board Resolutions | Refinement of string similarity review in IDN ccTLD Fast Track Process | ICANN.orgResolved (2017.10.29.05), the Board thanks the ccNSO, GAC and SSAC for collaborating to address the issue related to string similarity review and for developing the "Joint ccNSO SSAC Response to ICANN Board on EPSRP". Resolved (2017.10.29.06), the [ICANN] Board approves amending the Final Implementation Plan for IDN ccTLD Fast Track Process as suggested in the Joint ccNSO SSAC Response. The President and CEO, or his Designee(s), is directed to incorporate the amendment into the Implementation Plan previously adopted by the Board on 30 October 2009 (and amended on 5 November 2013) and implement the amendment as soon as practicable.

Approved Board Resolutions | Defer Compliance Enforcement of Thick WHOIS Consensus Policy for 180 Days | ICANN.org: "Resolved (2017.10.29.04), the President and CEO, or his designee(s), is authorized to defer compliance enforcement of the Thick Whois Consensus Policy for 180 days to allow additional time for the registrars and Verisign to reach agreement on amendments needed to applicable registry-registrar agreements to implement the Policy and for Registrars to undertake system modifications required to enable the thin to thick migration and additional modifications, if any, required for GDPR compliance."

Minutes – Board Risk Committee (BRC) Meeting | ICANN.org 2 Nov 2017: "... ICANN organization will consider moving to a different auditor next year when it moves to NIST framework. One significant change ICANN organization has made internally this year was to reorganize within the engineering and IT function and integrated cybersecurity (which used to be a stand-alone function) with DNS engineering and networking teams. It was noted that cloud based security testing is becoming a part of ICANN organization's normal rhythm as 40 percent of the services utilized at ICANN leverages some aspect of cloud."

Letter from ICANN General Counsel & Secretary John O. Jeffrey to Jetse Sprey | ICANN.org:
01 Nov 2017 Issue: Gemeente Amsterdam FRL Registry B.V. (new gTLDs .FRL, .AMSTERDAMjeffrey-to-sprey-01nov17-en.pdf [604 KB] "... your clients appear to have violated its obligations under the Registry Agreement ..."

3) Names, Domains & Trademarks
EFF to ICANN: Don't Pick Up the Censor's Pen | Electronic Frontier Foundation | EFF.org: "... And ICANN largely has itself to blame, by including in its 2013 revision to its agreement with registrars a provision requiring registrars to "receive reports of abuse involving Registered Names" and to "take reasonable and prompt steps to investigate and respond appropriately." This leaves ICANN open to an argument that goes, "No of course we are not asking you to become the content police, we are simply asking you to enforce your own contracts with registrars, when they refuse to carry out their obligations to be content police." ICANN appears to have voluntarily taken on further responsibility for addressing "abuse involving" domain names through its appointment this year of a Consumer Safeguards Director with a background in law enforcement. EFF attended and reported on the first webinar held by the new Director, in which he downplayed the significance of his role, stating that it does not carry any enforcement powers. Yet a draft report [PDF] of ICANN's Competition, Consumer Trust and Consumer Choice Review Team recommends that strict new enforcement and reporting obligations should be made compulsory for any new top-level domains that ICANN adopts in the future. ICANN's Non-Commercial Stakeholder Group (NCSG) has explained [PDF] why many of these recommendations would be unnecessary and harmful ..."

See also: EFF to ICANN's Registrars: Don't Pick Up the Censor's Pen | EFF.org and 

EFF to ICANN's Registries: Don't Pick Up the Censor's Pen | EFF.org: "... Our whitepaper broke down these choices in detail, explaining how some of the weakest protection for free speech comes from those domain registries whose policies offer additional privileges to trademark or copyright holders, or to overseas speech regulators. Amongst the worst examples that we called out were Donuts and Radix, who have a side-deal with the Motion Picture Association of America (MPAA), bestowing it with a "Trusted Notifier" status that allows it to recommend domains for the registrars to suspend, without review by a court. We also called out the Domain Name Association (DNA) for a Shadow Regulation-style proposal to construct a private copyright arbitration system for its member registries, which include the Public Interest Registry (PIR) responsible for .org domains, and to promote that system of private law as an industry standard. This proposal was developed behind closed doors, fueling our concerns about its capture by copyright holders. Although the DNA and PIR shelved these plans after EFF brought them to light, the DNA is still pushing a similar pharmaceutical industry-penned policy that would allow for the rapid suspension of domains used for online medicine sales, bypassing any legal process. To give a final example, the new gTLDs contain an excessive level of protection for trademark holders when compared with most of the original gTLDs and ccTLDs. ICANN has imposed the requirement that all new gTLD registries utilize a secret Trademark Clearinghouse database to give priority access to brand owners when first offering their new domains for sale ("Sunrise Protection"), and to warn off registrants who register domains that might give rise to a trademark claim. Some registries have gone even further to offer brand owners additional protections that the ICANN community had rejected as requirements for the new gTLD program. An example is Donuts' DPML-Plus program that prevents the public from registering new domains that are merely typographically similar to a trademarked brand ..."

Google no longer lets you change domains to search different countries | TheVerge.com: "Google said that it’ll now deliver search results relevant to your current location no matter which domain you visit. So if you’re in New York and visit google.ru, you’ll still get results relevant to New York City. Fortunately, it’ll still be possible to escape your country’s results. You’ll be able to change locations, you’ll just have to do it through the settings menu at the bottom of google.com ... The policy of always serving local results will now apply to desktop and mobile searches, as well as Google Maps and the iOS Google app."

4) ICYMI Internet Domain News 
US Federal Court Rejects Global Search Order | EFF.org"... a federal court in the US has weighed in on a thorny question: Does Google US have to obeyCanadian court order requiring Google to take down information around the world, ignoring contrary rules in other jurisdictions? According to the [U.S. District Court for the] Northern District of California, the answer is no. The case is Google v. Equustek ..."

Data Breaches: U.S. Sen. John Thune (R-S.D.), chairman of the Committee on Commerce, Science, and Transportation, will convene a hearing titled “Protecting Consumers in the Era of Major Data Breaches,” at approximately 10:00 a.m. on Wednesday, November 8, 2017, to examine data breaches. The hearing will feature testimony from current CEO of Equifax and past Yahoo! CEO Marissa Mayer.--U.S. Senate Committee On Commerce, Science, & Transportation | commerce.senate.gov.

The DDoS Attack Against Dyn One Year Later | forbes.com"... we now find news of a botnet which is reportedly spreading on IoT devices again ..."

Nov 4-5, celebrate the life and work of Aaron Swartz at the Fifth Annual Aaron Swartz Day and Hackathon | blog.archive.org.  Aaron would have turned 31 on November 8.--eff.org

5) Top 3 Most Read Posts (# of pageviews Sun-Sat) this past week on DomainMondo.com: 
1. Securing Consumer Credit Data in the Age of Digital Commerce (video)

2. News Review | ICANN60, Abu Dhabi, ICANN Board Suspends SSR2 Work

3. Ad Agencies & Brands Vs Google $GOOG, Facebook $FB, Amazon $AMZN

-- John Poole, Editor, Domain Mondo 

feedback & comments via twitter @DomainMondo


DISCLAIMER

2017-10-29

News Review | ICANN60, Abu Dhabi, ICANN Board Suspends SSR2 Work

News Review | ©2016 DomainMondo.com
Domain Mondo's weekly internet domain news review (NR 2017-10-29) with analysis and opinion: Features •  1) ICANN60, Abu Dhabi, ICANN Board Suspends SSR2 Work, 2)Other ICANN news: a. WS2 Plenary re ICANN Jurisdiction, ... e.Will Puerto Rico Be Ready for ICANN61, 3) Names, Domains & Trademarks: Verisign $VRSN Q3 2017 results,  Blockchain & Domains, ccTLD .AU4) ICYMI: Apple, China and Internet Censorship, 5) Most Read Posts.

1)  ICANN60 | Abu Dhabi | Annual General Meeting 28 Oct - 3 Nov 2017
graphic: ICANN60 | Abu Dhabi  ©2017 DomainMondo.com

ICANN60 | Abu Dhabi meeting schedule--mobile: https://schedule.icann.org/mobile/#page:page-schedule--highlighted sessions (times shown are local Abu Dhabi unless otherwise indicated):
  • Sunday, Oct 29, 13:30 - 14:00 GAC Meeting with Amazon.com "The GAC will be meeting with the Amazon Company in order to discuss the Independent Review Process (IRP)"
  • Tuesday, October 31 • 12:15 - 13:15 Internet Governance Public Forum "This Public Session will explore and discuss the global Internet Governance agenda making reference to the outcome of the ITU WTDC and looking forward to the 2017 IGF and GCCS conference. It will also consider trends in the Internet Governance Ecosystem post the IANA Transition."
  • Wednesday, Nov 1, 14:00 - 15:00  ICANN GDD: Update on ICANN Domain Name Registrant Work"This session will provide the community with an update on the Domain Name Registrant work being carried out by GDD, including how information from registrants' contact with ICANN Global Support Center is used to inform the work, the registrants educational series, as well as engagement with the community."
ICANN60 Oct 28, 2017: ICANN Board Suspends Work of SSR2 Review Team
UPDATES:
Nov. 3: SSR2-RT Face-to-Face meeting in Abu Dhabi (see session link above for more info)

Nov 2ICANN60 | Abu Dhabi: Joint Meeting: ICANN Board & SSR2 Review Team (closed meeting) Thursday, November 2 • 13:45 - 15:00.

Oct 30Transcript--ICANN60 | Abu Dhabi--ccNSO/GNSO Joint Council Meeting, Monday, 30 October 2017 12:15 GST (pdf) embed below, highlighting added starting at page 21:

Oct 29: reaction to the Board's letter of October 28 (below) at ICANN60, ranges from shock (SSR2 Mail List) to befuddlement at the ICANN GNSO session today, as apparently no one at ICANN60 knows the specifics (other than the Board and SSAC--and so far neither is talking specifics) which caused the ICANN Board to take this unprecedented and questionable action. A key video replay from an ICANN60 session today has been hidden from the public behind a VPN sign-in which forced this complaint to be filed today.--Update Oct 30: the issue has now been fixed per ICANN Complaints Office, and I reviewed Sunday's Adobe Connect replay of the SSR2 outreach public session, but no information was disclosed relating to the Board's or SSAC's issues with SSR2. Co-Chair Denise Michel told GNSO on Sunday that the SSR2-RT had received no "actionable information" from either the Board or SSAC.

UPDATE via Public Forum #1 Oct 30, 2017:
Steve Delbianco:  "Thank you, Steve Delbianco with the Business Constituency within ICANN … I was troubled this week when the Board under that mandate decided to pause one of the reviews, the SSR2 review, and Rinalia Abdul Rahim [ICANN Board member] today explained that in your obligation to cause a review, you certainly would want to hit pause if you had any reason to believe the review wouldn't happen according to the bylaws.  And I appreciate a heads-up, if that's the case. But my question for you is: having hit pause, does the community need to come back to the board to hit the play button, to hit the resume button again?  Or can we exercise the authority I think the bylaws give us to pay attention to your heads-up, your alert, but it's up to us to resolve any considerations with respect to the scope, composition, or structure and it's up to you in the ACs and SOs to determine we're going to go ahead and resume or hit the play button after you hit the pause button?  So I'd love to hear your answer on this so we can get past this and move on.  Thank you."
Cherine Chalaby, ICANN Board Vice Chair:  "Steve, thank you very much for the question. The answer is very simple.  It's really the Board is backing the community's hand and it's up to you to resume when you want to resume.  It's not for the board to tell you when.  All we did is we fulfilled our fiduciary responsibility.  We saw something wasn't working well.  We raised it to you.  We asked for a pause.  And you then -- it's up to you to decide when you want to resume and how you want to resume."
Later comment at the Forum from Jonathan Zuck (Innovator's Network): "... following on Steve Delbianco's comment,  I guess I fear that he let the Board off the hook maybe a little too easily in his presentation  and I really want to bring to the surface the notion that the optics of how this all went down with the SSR2 are not good ..."  
Response from Steve Crocker, ICANN Board Chair: "... The current situation is that the issues have been identified, we can spend time here if we want to go into it a little bit more.  We wrote a letter a couple of hours ago laying out more background and so forth, that's intended to be the beginning of a consultation process that the Supporting Organizations and Advisory Committees are intended to partake in.  The Board does not like -- I can absolutely assure you that we took no relish in this.  We don't view it as a comfortable situation  and we absolutely are not trying to either stop it or control it in detail.  And we have no stake for ourselves for sure in any of the issues and we're not particularly trying to protect the organization, but we do care a lot about the use of the resources, we do care a lot about whether there is a sensible, organized process and that the internal dynamics are effective.  So I'll stop there, unless you want to press further.”
Oct 30 UpdateEditor's note: the "letter" identified by Steve Crocker above was published late today (pdf) by ICANN, embed below (highlighting added):


[Editor's note: Like most domain name registrants, I will not be in Abu Dhabi, and like most in North America, I will be fast asleep during most ICANN60 sessions. Next week's News Review will have an ICANN60 recap drawn from various sources, including some of those shown below.]

ICANN Meeting Media Resources:
ICANN FY17 Audited Financial Statements [PDF, 212 KB]--p.27: "ICANN’s President and CEO, Göran Marby, has an employment agreement with ICANN through May 2021. Pursuant to that employment agreement, Mr. Marby is entitled to an annual base salary of $653,846 and at-risk compensation of up to $196,154 – not to exceed a total of $850,000 annually per year based on the President’s and CEO’s achievement of the established performance goals."
PTI FY17 Audited Financial Statements [PDF, 124 KB].
Payments to ICANN Directors (1 Jul 2016 - 30 Jun 2017) highlighting added:

ICANN60, Abu Dhabi (click on image below to go to Google Map of ICANN60 venue):
وكالة أنباء الإمارات - TRA hosts ICANN’s 60th Public Meeting | wam.ae"The Telecommunications Regulatory Authority, TRA, will host the 60th International Public Meeting, ICANN60, of the Internet Corporation for Assigned Names and Numbers, ICANN, at the Abu Dhabi National Exhibition Centre, ADNEC, from 28th October to 3rd November 2017." 

2) Other ICANN news
a. ICANN Jurisdiction: CCWG-Accountability WS2 Plenary, Friday Oct 27, Abu Dhabi | DomainMondo.com: links to recordings, documents, chat, transcripts. The Jurisdiction Subgroup Draft Recommendations passed a successful second reading at the WS2 Plenary on Oct 27, 2017.

b. DNSSEC Root Key Operations and the Infineon Smartcard Bug | ICANN.org: "... we believe that the DNSSEC KSKs are not subject to this vulnerability. However, no system is perfect ..."  (emphasis added) [Editor's Note: comforting words from ICANN?]

c. ICANN Public Comment periods closing in November at  23:59 UTC on closing date indicated (subject to change):

d. IANA Transition costs through Sep 2017? $33.4 million of which lawyers grabbed $15 million:

e. ICANN61 | San JuanWill Puerto Rico be ready by 10-15 Mar 2018? See status.pr and FEMA.gov. 17 Oct 2017: "Over the next several months, the Puerto Rico Electric Power Authority (PREPA), United States Army Corps of Engineers (USACE), the Department of Energy, and private industry will unite to restore emergency power to Puerto Rico’s electric grid, which was heavily damaged by hurricanes Irma and Maria. Currently, only 14 percent of Puerto Rico has electricity ...."--FEMA.gov. 

3) Names, Domains & Trademarks
•  Verisign $VRSN Q3 2017 results:
  • Financials: revenue of $292 million for the third quarter of 2017, up 1.7 percent from the same quarter in 2016. Verisign reported net income of $115 million and diluted earnings per share (diluted “EPS”) of $0.93 for the third quarter of 2017, compared to net income of $114 million and diluted EPS of $0.90 for the same quarter in 2016. The operating margin was 61.9 percent for the third quarter of 2017 compared to 60.8 percent for the same quarter in 2016.
  • .COM and .NET: At the end of September, 2017, domain name base registrations in .COM and .NET totaled 145.8 million, consisting of 130.8 million .COM domain name registrations, and 15 million .NET. The .COM and .NET domain name base increased by 1.47 million net names during the third quarter after processing 8.9 million new gross registrations which benefited from continued strength from U.S.-based registrars.
  • Renewal Rate: Verisign projects renewal rate for third quarter of 2017 will be 74.3%.
  • Q4 2017 guidance: Verisign expects increase to the .COM and .NET domain name base during Q4 2017 between 0.4 million to 0.9 million registrations, consistent with a full year 2017 growth rate of 2.8% to 3.1%.
  • New gTLD .WEB update: no new news, although there is activity, the process is ongoing. "We are continuing to cooperate with the Justice Department regarding the CID ..."--James Bidzos, Verisign CEO, October 26, 2017.

•  Blockchain & Domains? Undeveloped.com Oct 20--The Future Of The Domain Industry Lies In Blockchain--"... Domains are currently illiquid assets. We can change that. Anyone will be able to invest in premium domains and entire domain portfolio’s after we introduce fractional domain ownership. This can lead to the inception of the first stock exchange for domains. And that’s just the start ..."

•  ccTLD .AUauDA welcomes Federal Government review of .au domain | auda.org.au. The next step is Australia's Department of Communications and the Arts will shortly release a discussion paper seeking input from interested industry and community stakeholders with the review expected to be finalized by early 2018.--Terms of Reference for a review of the .au Domain Administration | Department of Communications and the Arts.

4) ICYMI Internet Domain News 
  • Apple, China & Internet Censorship--US Senators Cruz, Leahy Probe Apple’s Stance on Chinese Internet Censorship:"Cruz was a lead opponent of the U.S. government’s 2016 handover of technical internet oversight to a nonprofit—out of concerns that such a move could open the door to online censorship. Cruz had questioned the role of Fadi Chehadé, former CEO of the nonprofit Internet Corporation for Assigned Names and Numbers (ICANN), in the China-organized World Internet Conference and whether that made ICANN complicit in China’s censorship practices."--BNA.com. See also: Senators press Apple to explain removal of apps in China | TheHill.com.
  • Sky Views: China has won the internet's future | news.sky.com"... We're edging closer to the Chinese model. Perhaps because we've realised, with the original freewheeling dream of cyberspace gone, there's not much to choose between the Chinese approach and Facebook, Google and the rest. Both models of sovereignty - rule by an authoritarian state or rule by digital platform - rely on surveillance, whether in the service of political control or of free-market capitalism. For a long time, the Chinese approach to the internet appeared to be a relic of a repressive past. These days, depressingly, it looks like the future."
5) Top 4 Most Read Posts (# of pageviews Sun-Sat) this past week on DomainMondo.com: 

     2. News Review (Oct22)| Brazil Opposes Draft Report re: ICANN U.S. Jurisdiction

     3. Q3 2017 Earnings Webcasts Oct 26: $TWTR, $GOOGL, $VRSN, $AMZN


-- John Poole, Editor, Domain Mondo 

feedback & comments via twitter @DomainMondo


DISCLAIMER

Domain Mondo archive