Showing posts with label gTLD. Show all posts
Showing posts with label gTLD. Show all posts

2019-06-23

News Review | ICANN65 June 24-27: EPDP, AMAZON & ICANN

graphic "News Review" ©2016 DomainMondo.com
Domain Mondo's weekly internet domain news review (NR 2019-06-23) with analysis and opinion: Features •  1) ICANN65, Marrakech, Morocco, June 24-27: EPDP, .AMAZON & ICANN, 2) Other ICANN news: New gTLD .AFRICA Litigation Update, 3) a. Voice.com Record Sale Price, b. Website Security & Malware, 4) ICYMI: The Internet Is Changing Africa, 5) Most Read.

1) ICANN65, Marrakech, Morocco, June 24-27
 ICANN65 Marrakech ©2019 DomainMondo.com (graphic)
Date & Time (24-hour clock) in Marrakech:

The ICANN Policy Forum is the second meeting in ICANN's three-meeting annual cycle, duration is four (4) days, and format is focused on SO/AC/SG/C policy work and outreach, and therefore:  no welcome ceremony;  no public forum(s);  no public board meeting.

ICANN65 Schedule (all times local Marrakech), *Schedule Highlights below:

*GAC: New gTLDs Subsequent Procedures Discussion 15:15 - 16:15, Mon, Jun 24 [10:15am EDT in U.S.] "Assess progress of PDP WG deliberations on issues of importance to the GAC. Discuss formation and operation of the GAC Focal Group on Subsequent Rounds of gTLDs."

*GNSO-EPDP Phase 2 Meeting (1 of 2)  8:30 - 15:00, Tue, Jun 25 --Notes & Action Items

*GNSO-EPDP Phase 2 Meeting (2 of 2)  8:30 - 15:00, Thu, Jun 27 --Notes & Action Items

EPDP background: CPH comments on Purposes (pdf), SO/AC/SG/C early input, and last week's News Review 2)b. Links to the EPDP meetings' recordings and transcripts (when available) are posted on the GNSO calendarOther EPDP Links: wikipublic mail list, legal memos & mail listGNSO mail listworksheetsdefinitions. Jun 20 meeting notes / action items.

*GAC: DNS Abuse Mitigation and dot Amazon Discussions 8:30 - 10:15, Tue, Jun 25
.AMAZON gTLD vs. Amazon homeland (graphic)
Editor's note: read Amazon wins ‘.amazon’ domain name, aggravating South American region and undermining digital commons | theconversation.com, excerpt:
"... At its inception, the internet was a great equaliser. It meant large and small businesses could compete with one another on a level playing field. ICANN has been entrusted with administering the internet and protecting it. That means protecting its broader purpose in society. ICANN appears to have forgotten that part of its role. It now charges costs USD$185,000 for a top-level domain name like “.amazon”. It’s not surprising that a company whose 2018 profits were reportedly USD$11.2 billion – for which it paid no federal taxes – was able to purchase the domain before an indigenous community in Brazil. The implications for the future of the internet are troubling. What was a global commons may become an exclusive field where those who have the most can acquire more. Those who have the least meanwhile lose even the right to use the name of their homeland." (emphasis added) [See also the author's letter to ICANN Board (pdf)]
The .AMAZON issues illustrate how ill-conceived and corrupt the entire .BRAND new gTLDs program is--a "brand" a/k/a "trademark" is neither monopoly nor generic, and therefore all ".BRAND gTLDs" fail as "generic top-level domains" (gTLDs), see RFC 1591. The .BRAND new gTLDs program was a way for incompetent, corrupt, unfit ICANN, and some of its contracted parties, i.e., registry service providers, to make money by extorting trademark holders--"apply for a .BRAND new gTLD or ICANN may sell your .BRAND (trademark) gTLD to someone else"-- e.g., see .PING testimony. Most .BRAND gTLDs are primarily a costly expense in trademark defense (instead, ICANN should have given trademark holders a right to block any gTLD application that infringes a legitimate distinctive trademark, and governmental authorities the right to block any gTLD application that is for a recognized or protected geographic term under applicable law). Unsurprisingly, many .BRAND gTLDs have been abandoned and returned to ICANN, while .BRANDs like .GOOGLE (and .AMAZON), in effect, contribute to the splintering of the internet into a few monopolistic platforms, smothering all competitors, undermining the digital commons and the core internet principle that all TLDs are "global public resources"--see U.S. amicus brief in the Weinstein case.
"... ICANN is a corrupt racketeering organization. It's a crime syndicate that advances interests of a few insiders at the expense of the masses and the general good. They have abused their power and their role ..."
The GAC-ICANN Board discussion re: .AMAZON (1:07:50-1:55:00) Wednesday morning via Livestream below:

*Evolving the Effectiveness of ICANN's Multistakeholder Model  17:00 - 18:30, Tue, Jun 25  (Livestream video below)

*Impacts of EPDP Phase 1 Recommendations on Other ICANN Policies and Procedures 15:15 - 16:45, Thu, Jun 27, 2019 (10:15am EDT) slide deck, Livestrean video below:

ICANN Meeting & Media Resources:
  • "A simple way to focus your attention is to listen with the intention of summarizing the other person’s point of view. This stops you from using your mental energy to work out your reply, and helps store the other’s words in your memory as well as identify any gaps in your understanding so you can ask questions to clarify."--fs.blog.

2) Other ICANN News
graphic "ICANN | Internet Corporation for Assigned Names and Numbers"
New gTLD .AFRICA Litigation Update: 
new gTLD .AFRICA (graphic)
DotConnectAfrica Trust, a Mauritius Charitable Trust, Plaintiff, v. Internet Corporation for Assigned Names and Numbers (ICANN), a California Corporation; ZA Central Registry, a South African non-profit company; and DOES 1-50, inclusive; Defendants:
new gTLD .AFRICA litigation in Los Angeles (case style)
May 21, 2019: "On the Court's own motion, the Trial Setting Conference scheduled for 05/21/2019, and NonJury Trial On Phase I (Estoppel) scheduled for 05/21/2019 are continued to 07/11/19  [July 11, 2019] at 10:00 AM in Department 53 at Stanley Mosk Courthouse ..."

3) Names, Domains & Trademarks: Website Security & Malware
graphic "Names, Domains & Trademarks" ©2017 DomainMondo.com
a. Largest publicly reported all cash domain name sale in history revealed June 18, 2019, the $30 million sale of Voice.com, more than double the previous record of $13 million paid for Sex.com in 2010.

b. Website Security & Malware: More Than 150,000 Small-Business Websites in the U.S. could be infected with malware at any given moment--in one case, security firm SiteLock (sitelock.com) discovered the hackers had exploited a security hole in a Wordpress plugin--see A Cybersecurity Checklist for the Modern Small BusinessAlso: FBI warns users to be wary of phishing sites abusing HTTPS.

4) ICYMI Internet Domain News 
graphic "ICYMI Internet Domain News" ©2017 DomainMondo.com
The Internet Is Changing Africa: cheap smartphones are flooding Africa, bringing internet access to many for the very first time, but there are problems: gambling, particularly sports betting in Africa's more developed nations, with about 60 million Nigerians aged between 18 and 40 betting daily.  China is investing in infrastructure, but with that comes Huawei equipment, e.g., China built the African Union building in Ethiopia, including installation of tapped networking equipment [the building was built in 2012 by the Chinese, the African Union's IT staff later discovered that the entire content of its servers was being transferred to China.]

WeChat Is Watching: WeChat's data centralization has inextricably linked it to all aspects of daily life in China and made it a cornerstone of the government's social-credit system.

2019-05-19

News Review | Afilias vs ICANN, IRP UPDATE re: new gTLD .WEB

graphic "News Review" ©2016 DomainMondo.com
Domain Mondo's weekly internet domain news review (NR 2019-05-19) with analysis and opinion: Features • 1) Afilias vs ICANN, IRP UPDATE re: new gTLD .WEB,  2) a. Dying Domains - CENTRstats, b. Type-in Traffic? c.Domain Parking?  d..AMAZON, 3) ICYMI: ANTITRUST; 4) Other ICANN News: a. SSAC on WHOIS; b. ICANN GNSO EPDP meeting May 23, 14:00 UTC c. New Reg Data Policy; 5)Most Read.

UPDATE 16 Jun 2019: News Review 2)a. Afilias v. ICANN .WEB IRP Update.

1) Afilias vs ICANN, IRP UPDATE re: new gTLD .WEB 
Afilias Domains No. 3 Limited vs ICANN re: new gTLD .WEB -- Editor's note: another 'document dump' (with redactions) posted by ICANN.org:

Declaration of Procedures Officer 28 February 2019:

Request for New Procedures Officer  8 March – 9 April 2019:

Amended Request for Independent Review Process 21 March 2019--Editor's note: "DAA" refers to NDC’s Domain Acquisition Agreement with VeriSign. 

Relief requested (p.25):
Editor's note: short on time? Read the Amended IRP Request, Zittrain and Sadowsky, skip the rest.

See also:

2) Names, Domains & Trademarks
graphic "Names, Domains & Trademarks" ©2017 DomainMondo.com
a. CENTRstats Global TLD Report Q1/2019: Download here; interactive online version of the report here. Highlights from the report:
  • The global TLD market is estimated at around 351 million domains [domain name registrations] across 1486 recorded TLDs. Total gTLD domain name registrations are 194 million of which 71% are under .COM.
  • The median domain growth of all TLDs has hit a record low of 3.4% year over year;
  • Only .COM is growing among the top 4 gTLDs -- the annual rates of +growth or -decline are as follows:  .com +5.2%.net -4.5%.org -1.9%.info - 24.2%.
  • As noted above, 71% of all gTLDs' domain name registrations are under .COM, which is also the world's largest TLD, with a 40% market share among all top-level domains (TLDs = ccTLDs + gTLDs);
  • 267 ccTLDs have a combined market share of 45% among all TLDs.
  • New gTLDs, "which include well over 1000 TLDs, have a little under 10% of the market and show no immediate sign of increasing that"... "gTLDs will face challenges in the coming months given other registration trends such as a declining create ratio, an increasing delete ratio and a relatively low renewal rate median of 64%."
Editor's note: the data and statistics compiled and reported by CENTR, an association of European ccTLD registries, is vastly superior to anything ever produced by incompetent ICANN.  Unlike ICANN, CENTR properly defines "registrant" [not "Registered Name Holder"]:
Registrant – "The individual or organisation that registers a specific domain name. A registrant holds the right to use that domain name for a specified period of time."
One possible future option for the global internet community is to have the world's ccTLDs run the IANA functions in view of the dysfunction at ICANN and its continuing debasement of the world's gTLDs.

b. Type-in Traffic? Chrome browser users who type characters into the address bar may notice the Google Chrome Browser prioritizes Google's search page over the intended destination (URL or  domain name)--ghacks.net. Example below:
Note: top line above is the user's entry into the Chrome address bar
c. Domain Parking? Multi-Million Dollar Domain Portfolio Owner says “Don’t Bother”--strategicrevenue.com. Editor's note: the Google & Facebook duopoly killed the advertising model.

d. .BRAND new gTLD .AMAZON:
On 15 May 2019,  the ICANN Board took action in accordance with the process established in the ICANN Board resolution adopted 10 March 2019, and in recognition of all input received, directing ICANN org to continue processing the .AMAZON applications toward delegation. The next step in the process is publication of the Public Interest Commitments (PICs), proposed by the the applicant, for a 30-day public comment period, per the established procedures of the New gTLD program. See 17 May 2019 Letter from ICANN CEO Göran Marby to Amb. Alexandra Moreira Lopez re: new gTLD .AMAZON.

3) ICYMI Internet Domain News: Antitrust
graphic "ICYMI Internet Domain News" ©2017 DomainMondo.com
ANTITRUST: U.S. Supreme Court dealt Apple major setback in App Store antitrust case--the iPhone users argued that Apple’s 30% commission on sales through the App Store is an unfair use of monopoly power resulting in inflated prices passed on to consumers. Apple unsuccessfully argued that only app developers, not users, should be able to bring such a lawsuit. Justice Brett Kavanaugh wrote the 5-4 majority opinion, joined in by the high court’s liberal justices. See also:
  • A New Google Antitrust Probe Could Spell Trouble for Its Auto Domination Plans--fortune.com.
  • ISP Antitrust: "Don’t Let California’s Legislature Extend Broadband Monopolies for Comcast and AT&T"--eff.org.
Editor's note: ICANN and its gTLD Registry Operators Next?

4) Other ICANN News
graphic "ICANN | Internet Corporation for Assigned Names and Numbers"
a.  ICANN Security and Stability Advisory Committee (SSAC)
SSAC 3 May 2019 letter to ICANN (pdf) excerpt: "WHOIS query statistics provided to ICANN by [gTLD] registry operators as part of their monthly reporting obligations are generally not reliable." (emphasis added).

b. ICANN GNSO EPDP Next Meeting May 23, 14:00 UTC (agenda, etc. at the link).
UPDATE: for the May 23rd meeting, see: Revised Draft Approach (pdf); RySG members feedback on proposed approach; comment of Alan Woods on access vs disclosure; comment of Milton Mueller on collaborating with ICANN Org, and his access/disclosure comment.

See also:
EPDP meeting recordings and transcripts (when available) are posted on the GNSO calendar. EPDP Links: wikipublic mail listGNSO mail list. See last week's News Review for more info, including the ICANN Board's rejection of two EPDP Phase 1 recommendations.

c. ICANN gTLD Registries and Registrars Required to Implement New Interim Registration Data Policy by 20 May 2019--ICANN.org.

5) Most Read this past week on DomainMondo.com: 
graphic "Domain Mondo" ©2017 DomainMondo.com

-- John Poole, Editor  Domain Mondo 

feedback & comments via twitter @DomainMondo


DISCLAIMER

2019-04-08

IGF 2019 Second Open Consultations and MAG Meeting, April 9-11

IGF 2019 Second Open Consultations and MAG Meeting
The fourteenth Annual Meeting of the Internet Governance Forum (IGF 2019) will be hosted by the Government of Germany in Berlin from 25 to 29 November 2019. 

In preparation for IGF 2019, the third face-to-face 2019 Open Consultations and MAG Meeting will take place on 5-7 June 2019 in Berlin, Germany. The meeting will be held on the premises of the German Federal Ministry of Economic Affairs and Energy, near the Berlin Hauptbahnhof (central railway station). See also: @sgdickinson and @UNSGdigicoop.


feedback & comments via twitter @DomainMondo


DISCLAIMER

2019-04-07

News Review 1) ICANN GNSO EPDP for gTLD Registration Data UPDATES

graphic "News Review" ©2016 DomainMondo.com
Domain Mondo's weekly internet domain news review (NR 2019-04-07) with analysis and opinion: Features •  1) ICANN GNSO EPDP for gTLD Registration Data Updates, 2) Other ICANN News: a..AMAZON, b..AFRICA, c. Free Speech at ICANN?  d. Trolls at ICANN? 3) .EU, .AU, Donuts & New gTLDs, History of the Web, 4) ICYMI: Facebook & Internet Regulators, Former Regulator Lu Wei gets 14 years, EU Censorship, and more, 5) Most Read.

1) ICANN GNSO EPDP for gTLD Registration Data Updates:
a. 5 April 2019 Letter from ICANN CEO Göran Marby (pdf) embed below, to GNSO Chair Keith Drazek re: 1. EPDP Team on the Temporary Specification for gTLD Registration Data Phase 1 Final
Report and 2. Technical Model by the Technical Study Group (TSG) on Access to Non-Public
Registration Data:

b. EPDP Status Update & Next Steps from EPDP interim Chair Rafik Dammak:
  • April 18 is target date for a new EPDP Chair to have been selected and approved by GNSO Council. Deadline for submitting "Expressions of Interest" in the position is April 8, 2019.
  • "Legal guidance next steps: The EPDP leadership team recommends that the legal committee is reconstituted as soon as possible, with meetings commencing shortly after reconstitution. In order to make the committee more effective, it is recommended that members have proven legal experience. Their role is not to advocate for their respective groups or positions, but to assess whether issues / questions raised by the EPDP Team are legal questions, have already been addressed elsewhere and channel any follow up to the EPDP Team's legal counsel. If at any point any member of the EPDP Team is of the view that the legal committee is going outside of its remit and/or individual members are not working for the best interest of the EPDP Team as a whole, the leadership team will review the membership structure."
  • EPDP Phase 2 Work Plans: The EPDP leadership team recommends splitting the work into  two work tracks/areas: 1) System for Standardized Access to Non-Public Registration Data; and 2) all other remaining issues (remaining issues from Annex: Important Issues for Further Community Action and Issues deferred from phase 1 - as outlined in the mind map (pdf) updated 10 March 2019).

c. Email to EPDP members from ICANN support staff 2 Apr 2019, action item coming out of the ICANN64 EPDP Team meetings: "start adding any legal questions you believe require a response in the context of the phase 2 identified topics"--see graphic below--no questions yet added:
"You are also encouraged to highlight any specific legal guidance that has already been provided ... that may be of relevance to the upcoming deliberations." See Legal Memos provided by Bird & Bird to ICANN GNSO EPDP.

2) Other ICANN News
graphic "ICANN | Internet Corporation for Assigned Names and Numbers"
a. .AMAZON: Amazon's Fight With South American Countries Over Control of '.amazon' Domain Name Comes to a Head--"... on March 10, ICANN set a deadline of April 7 for the two sides to finally resolve this dispute once and for all. But that seems very unlikely ..."--gizmodo.com. See BBC.com: "The nations of the Amazon want the name back." See previously on Domain MondoNews Review | Another ICANN New gTLD Disaster: .AMAZON.

Editor's notethe idea of having private .BRAND gTLDs was a mistake from the beginning, a corruption of the concept of generic top-level domains (gTLDs) as set forth in RFC 1591 written by Jon Postelwhich predates the formation of  ICANN and its "Californication" of the internet and global DNS. I'm with the South American countries. ICANN should do the "right thing" for once and end the .BRAND gTLD program, refund the application fees, and "undelegate" all .BRAND gTLDs from the internet "root," while allowing every owner of a distinctive trademark to block use of that mark as a gTLD in the future.

b. .AFRICA Litigation Update: 
 .AFRICA
DotConnectAfrica Trust v. ICANN et al (Trial Court Proceeding)

c. Free Speech at ICANN? Follow the blog posts of well known domainer, and active ICANN participant observer, George Kirikos, on his new blog at FreeSpeech.com.

Editor's notethere are no "winners" in this matter, which I now refer to as Greg Shatan vs George Kirikos vs ICANN et al, and there are many with "unclean hands." Hopefully the ICANN Ombudsman will bring some "sanity" to the situation.

d. Trolls at ICANN?
Mark Svancarek, Microsoft, at ICANN64, Kobe, Japan (photo)
Mark Svancarek, Microsoft, at ICANN64, Kobe, Japan
Mark Svancarek revealed this week on the EPDP mail list, that "Over the last several months, UASG lists have been exposed to one or more pseudonymous trolls who attack certain officers and ambassadors by name, and criticize decisions made in accordance with our charter which they feel merit their input; when we ban them, he/they just create multiple new aliases.  Sometimes they email us directly ..." [link and emphasis added]. 

Svancarek is Principal Program Manager, Privacy & Regulatory Affairs, Tech Policy & Internet Governance, at Microsoft. He has been an active participant in ICANN as Vice Chair of the Universal Acceptance Steering Group (UASG), as well as EPDP member from the Business Constituency.

3) Names, Domains & Trademarks
graphic "Names, Domains & Trademarks" ©2017 DomainMondo.com
  • New gTLDs Registry Operator Donuts raising wholesale domain name prices 6-9% on most of its 241 TLDs, effective October 1, 2019.  Editor's note: when you find out your "products" have limited appeal, all you can do is raise prices on those gullible enough to have fallen for your over-hyped product in the first place and are "stuck." Domain names are "sticky" not "fungible" which is why ICANN's entire model for new gTLDs is so ill-conceived. Too bad ICANN didn't listen to the U.S. Department of Justice Antitrust Division.

4) ICYMI Internet Domain News 
graphic "ICYMI Internet Domain News" ©2017 DomainMondo.com
Internet Regulation: Facebook Chief Executive Mark Zuckerberg has called upon regulators to play a “more active role” in establishing rules that govern the internet. Reactions:
  • Mark Zuckerberg Does Not Speak for the Internet--eff.org.
  • Why we should say No to Facebook’s call to “Regulate the Internet”--internetgovernance.org.
  • The Real Reasons Why Facebook's Zuckerberg Wants More Government Regulation--zerohedge.com: 1. Regulations Will Give Facebook More Monopoly Power (make things more expensive and difficult for smaller startups and potential competitors). 2. Zuckerberg and Facebook Will Help Write the New Rules. 3. It Will Limit Facebook's Legal Exposure.

China: A Chinese court has jailed former chief internet regulator, Lu Wei, for 14 years, having found the once influential official guilty of taking bribes worth almost $5 million from 2002 to 2017, including as head of the Cyberspace Administration of China (CAC). Lu Wei at ICANN50 in June, 2014, at London:
Editor's note: it's possible that ICANN paid Wei "bribes," directly or indirectly, during that same time. ICANN was doing every thing it could to garner support, or at least acceptance, from the Chinese government, in order to establish the "ICANN presence" in Beijing. We may never know for sure, ICANN has never been audited by the IRS. One thing is clear, Fadi Chehade, ICANN CEO at the time, acted strangely when quizzed about ICANN's expenditures and lobbying efforts with foreign governments, and never gave a straight answer nor the accounting he promised at the time. ICANN still doesn't disclose its lobbying activities and expenditures outside the U.S.

Can The EU Survive Its Own Censorship? The EU’s new, comprehensive Copyright Directive may change the way people use the internet--zerohedge.com.
Article 13 will damage the EU more than it damages the internet ... The EU will push itself away from the future
Google, Facebook Phished For Millions--Business email compromise (also called BEC, CEO or invoice fraud) usually targets finance and other corporate executives who are tricked into issuing payments that could be upwards of millions or hundreds of millions of dollars--cshub.com.

Microsoft obtained US court order to take control of 99 websites which Microsoft says are linked to Iranian hacking group Phosphorus--microsoft.com.

5) Most Read this past week on DomainMondo.com: 
graphic "Domain Mondo" ©2017 DomainMondo.com


-- John Poole, Editor  Domain Mondo 

feedback & comments via twitter @DomainMondo


DISCLAIMER

2019-03-03

News Review | GNSO Council EPDP Vote March 4, Phase 2 Next

graphic "News Review" ©2016 DomainMondo.com
Domain Mondo's weekly internet domain news review (NR 2019-03-03) with analysis and opinion: Features • 1) GNSO Council EPDP Vote March 4, Phase 2 Next,  2) ICANN64 March 9-14, and more, 3) The .COM Monopoly & ICANNand more, 4) ICYMI: Antitrust, Privacy, Internet Freedom, 5) Most Read.

UPDATES:
March 8, 2019, Reminder: Next EPDP Team meeting at ICANN64, Kobe, Japan, Saturday, 9 Mar 2019, 11:00-18:30 JST, (Friday 9:00 pm EST in US); agenda here, more info further below. Links for Adobe Connect and audio here. Slides here.

March 7, 2019: GNSO Council EPDP Vote Aftermath
  • WHOIS Reform, at Last--internetgovernance.org, by Milton Mueller (NCSG EPDP member): "Discussion of this issue has been distorted for years by ICANN’s propensity to cater to special interest groups (mainly trademark interests but also law enforcement agencies) who conflate their interest in getting access to Whois data with the actual purpose for collecting it. The temporary specification‘s discussion of Whois purpose was especially awful (See section 4, page 5). It is amazing how much progress was made having started from that baseline. The need to comply with GDPR, however, gave privacy advocates and the contracted parties a hammer with which to pound away illegitimate constructions of Whois purposes."
  • GNSO Council Meeting March 4, 2019, transcript (pdf) p. 16, Marie Pattullo, GNSO Councilor (BC), after voting "no" on the March 4th motions: "The EPDP’s work is incomplete. This is just Phase 1, and the report is a step backwards for BC members’ interests compared to the temp spec especially as the legitimate purposes for collecting and processing data in the report are insufficiently precise and don't include consumer protection, cyber clients, DNS abuse and IP protections."

March 4, 2019: GNSO Council approves the motions re: EPDP Final Report (Phase 1). The vote approving was unanimous in the Contracted Parties House (CPH) and split in the Non-Contracted Parties House (NCPH) with "No" votes from the Business Constituency (BC) and Intellectual Property Constituency (IPC). Planning for EPDP Phase 2 work was then discussed, excerpts from the presentation:
See also the "mind map" (pdf) prepared by ICANN staff.

1) GNSO Council Votes on EPDP Final Report March 4, EPDP Phase 2 Next
GNSO Council meeting March 4, 2019, 21:00 UTC (4:00 pm EST in U.S.). Agenda embed below.  Audio cast via browser or app. Transcripts and recordings on GNSO Calendar.
Agenda Item 3: COUNCIL VOTE - Adoption of the Final Report (pdf) on Expedited PDP on the Temporary Specification for gTLD Registration Data (45 minutes)
Agenda Item 4: COUNCIL DISCUSSION - Expedited PDP on the Temporary Specification for gTLD Registration Data - Phase 2 Work (45 minutes)
GNSO Council March 4 agenda (pdf) embed below:

Links: GNSO mail list, meeting documents and motions
EPDP Final Report voting threshold: Supermajority, ICANN Bylaws, Section 11.3(i)(xix): A "GNSO Supermajority" shall mean: (A) two-thirds (2/3) of the Council members of each House, or (B) three-fourths (3/4) of the Council members of one House and a majority of the Council members of the other House.
Next EPDP Team meeting: Saturday, 9 Mar 2019, 11:00-18:30 JST, (9:00 pm Friday EST in US) at ICANN64 in Kobe, Japan--agenda--"for Phase 2 planning, and a discussion on how to manage the coincident Implementation and Phase 2 efforts" according to an email from the EPDP leadership team.  Links for audio and Adobe Connect on the "EPDP Team meeting" link above. EPDP Linksmail list and wiki; EPDP Final Report (pdf); EPDP Charter (pdf); Bird & Bird legal memos; EPDP legal mail list, ICANN's controllership legal memo (pdf).

Rafik Dammak, EPDP Acting Chair
"The GNSO Council and the EPDP team leadership are currently working to develop a plan for addressing Phase 2 and we need to know if there will be changes to the composition of the group."--email from Rafik Dammak, March 1, 2019.
"... When I initially committed to join the group, my intention was to participate in the entirety of the ePDP but the Phase 1 commitment was extremely taxing so I’d like to get a little bit of an understanding of how the leadership group thinks the timing in Phase 2 will compare."--Matt Serlin
"Both Hadia and I plan to continue. That of course presumes we can come up with a REASONABLE work plan that will not kill us."--Alan Greenberg
"... I think many of us are in the situation which Matt describes.  Please, what is the timeline you anticipate?  Will there be face to face meetings, and if so is there a budget for travel?  Will we be keeping our independent counsel?  These are questions whose answers will  influence my decision."--Stephanie Perrin
Related--email from GNSO Chair Keith Drazek to GNSO Councilor (and EPDP member) Ayden Férdeline re: Draft - 2019 GNSO Council Strategic Planning Session Report:
"Hi Ayden, Thanks for your work on this. I have asked Steve to incorporate some of your stylistic edits and some additional language, but I don’t think we can include the commentary on the participation of other SO/AC members in the EPDP and suggestions that other groups are sending discredited and disruptive members to engage with the GNSO.  That’s not something we should include in our formal report on the SPS. Thanks, Keith" (emphasis added)
Search for New EPDP Chair: email Feb 28, 2019, from GNSO Chair Keith Drazek: "Following two Council leadership calls this week, we have finalized the attached Expression of Interest (EOI) [embed below] for the EPDP WG Phase 2 Chair. This will be posted tomorrow and the deadline for responses will be March 22. Our goal is to confirm the new Chair during our April 18 Council meeting. We wanted to be sure to get this posted as soon as possible and certainly in advance of Kobe. The substance of the EOI is the same as the version we used for Phase One. In the interim transition period, while we find a permanent Chair, Rafik [Dammak] will be Acting Chair." [link and emphasis added]

EOI for EPDP WG Phase 2 Chair (reformatted from the original for ease of reading):

EPDP Related: ICANN and GDPR – nowhere near compliance | edri.org 27 Feb 2019: "... while the [EPDP] Initial Report proposes a strong reliance on “legitimate purpose of the controller” as a legal basis for most of the data processing practices, it at no point shows that it has balanced those purposes with the interests of the data subjects. This lack of proportionality was an explicit concern of the WP29 opinion in 2003, and the Initial Report falls far short of the balancing tests as described in WP 29 Opinion 05/2014. Furthermore, the Initial Report doesn’t acknowledge the principle of data minimisation ..."
Editor's notebe sure to read the full thread--Ayden Férdeline (ferdeline.com) is a GNSO Councilor and EPDP member. He is a tech policy fellow with the Mozilla Foundation in Berlin, Germany.

See also
  • Ann Cairns, executive vice chairman of Mastercard, discussing the internet of things, digital identities, and data privacy regulation at the Mobile World Congress 2019, says Europe's approach to data protection will be adopted worldwide--CNBC International | YouTube.com.
  • Revealed: Facebook’s global lobbying against data privacy laws--Leaked Facebook memo describes company's lobbying efforts in 2012 and 2013 against a proposed European data directive which later became GDPR--theguardian.com.

2) Other ICANN News
graphic "ICANN | Internet Corporation for Assigned Names and Numbers"
 ICANN64 | Kobe
a. ICANN64 9-14 March 2019, Kobe, Japan: ICANN64 Schedule.
Date and time in Kobe, Japan:
Meeting resources:

b.  ICYMI this past week on Domain Mondo:
  • ICANN, New gTLDs, Trademarks, RPMs, & Website Content (video) with Rebecca Tushnet, Harvard Law School; Brian Winterfeldt, Winterfeldt IP Group; Mary Wong, ICANN; Becky Burr, ICANN Board & Neustar; Sarah Deutsch, ICANN Board; Kathy Kleiman, Center for Information Technology, Princeton University; Jeff Neuman, Com Laude/Valideus; Mitch Stoltz, EFF; Brian King, MarkMonitor; at a conference at the American University Washington College of Law, Washington, D.C., Feb. 25, 2019.

c. ICANN org publishes Charter on Government Engagement Approach--icann.org. See
draft charter (pdf).

d. ICANN CTO David Conrad to oversee IANA Services and Public Technical Identifiers (PTI)--icann.org.

e. 22 Feb 2019 Letter from Verisign (Patrick Kane) to ICANN (Cyrus Namazi) (pdf) embed below  re: Request for Thick WHOIS Consensus Policy Extension:

f. Cooperative Engagement Process (CEP) and Independent Review Process (IRP) Status Update 25 Feb 2019 (pdf) excerpts:
IRP proceeding: Afilias Domains No. 3 Limited re: new gTLD .WEB. IRP commenced on 26 November 2018; two panelists have been appointed; awaiting appointment of remaining panelist. No hearings are currently scheduled.
CEP proceedings:

g. ICANN & ITU--ICANN Submits Application to International Telecommunications Union (ITU) for ITU-D Sector membership.
Editor's note: Questions about this at @sgdickinson and CCWG-InternetGovernance.

h. ICANN org recommends gTLD registries and registrars to implement the February-2019 version of the gTLD RDAP profile in their RDAP service. Editor's note: the recommended RDAP profile is already out-of-date per EPDP Phase 1 Final Report. ICANN's gTLD registry operators and registrars are required to implement a RDAP service by 26 August 2019.

i. Public Note (pdf) concerning the case of the gTLD “.AMAZON”
 Brazilian Internet Steering Committee
To: ICANN Board of Directors and GAC re: ICANN Board Resolutions 2019.01.16.02 – 2019.01.16.04
"The Brazilian Internet Steering Committee – CGI.br, exercising the mandate conferred upon it by Decree no. 4.829/2003 ... Endorses the request made by the Brazilian government in its letter to the ICANN Board of Directors, dated February 21, 2019, 'to postpone a final decision on the .AMAZON application to ICANN 65, with a view to allow the eight Amazon countries and Amazon Inc. to find a mutually acceptable solution.'"

3) Names, Domains & Trademarks
graphic "Names, Domains & Trademarks" ©2017 DomainMondo.com
a. The .COM Monopoly & ICANN--breakingviews.com: "... ICANN could reject the price hikes. Then again, Verisign may offer to increase the nonprofit’s cut in exchange for agreeing to the increases. A public consultation should help keep both groups honest, but the risk remains that a sweetheart deal gets even sweeter."

b.  Tucows $TCX Q4 2018 Q&A Transcript (pdf), excerpt: "With respect to domain portfolio sales, our portfolio of domains that we hold for resale in the aftermarket is something that we consider tactical, not strategic, as an asset. The bulk portfolio sale in Q4 2018 was generated from our non-surname portfolio of names held."

c. Once You’ve Filed a UDRP, There May Be No Going Back--Lexology.com: "1. Do not file frivolous UDRP complaints ..."

4) ICYMI Internet Domain News 
graphic "ICYMI Internet Domain News" ©2017 DomainMondo.com
Antitrust Enforcement Needs to Evolve for the 21st Century--eff.org.

EFF Supporting California’s Privacy For All Bill, Which Puts People, Not Tech Companies, in Control of Personal Data--eff.org.

Authoritarian assault on Internet Freedom is on the move in Russia and India--editorial in the washingtonpost.com..

India presses on with internet regulations--Chinese-style censorship feared after government consults with tech giants--asia.nikkei.com.

Domain Mondo archive