Feature • Incompetent ICANN used a reportedly "junk science" firm for its new gTLDs economic studies:
Compass Lexecon, firm used by #ICANN for #newgTLDs economic studies, criticized for "junk science" https://t.co/RSv2NDr8uE— George Kirikos (@GeorgeKirikos) November 17, 2016
“The answer is known in advance, either because you created what the client wanted or the client selected you as the most favorable..."— George Kirikos (@GeorgeKirikos) November 17, 2016
Accountability and Transparency at ICANN - An Independent Review Appendix C (pdf): The Introduction of New gTLDs, October 20, 2010 | The Berkman Center for Internet & Society at Harvard University pp 9-10 (highlighting added):"Compass economists can reach very different answers to the same question, depending on who is paying them."— George Kirikos (@GeorgeKirikos) November 17, 2016
For more see: These Professors Make More Than a Thousand Bucks an Hour Peddling Mega-Mergers | ProPublica.org: "Earlier this year, a top Justice Department official criticized Compass Lexecon for using “junk science.” ProPublica sent a detailed series of questions to Compass Lexecon for this story. The firm declined to comment on the record .... Carlton’s predictions did not pan out ..." Also see:
- Dennis Carlton, “Comments on Michael Kende’s Assessment of Preliminary Reports on Competition and Pricing,” Compass Lexecon (June 5, 2009).
- Dennis Carlton, “ICANN’s Proposed Mechanism for Introducing New gTLDs,” Compass Lexecon (June 5, 2009).
- Dennis Carlton, “Preliminary Report – Impact of New gTLDs on Consumer Welfare,” Compass Lexecon (March 2009).
- Dennis Carlton, “Preliminary Report – Price Caps for New gTLD Internet Registries,” Compass Lexecon (March 2009).
- New gTLD Economic Study Phase II Report is Released (2010) | ICANN.org
- ICANN Email Archives: [5gtld-guide]: "Economic "Study" Phase II does not make the case for new TLDs - ICANN and authors should be ashamed to present this "work" to the public"--"... Now, on to the latest "paper". Briefly, it is junk, and mere intellectual masturbation. It once again lacks any empirical rigour. It also ignores what the Department of Commerce letter of 2008 *told* ICANN to study: http://www.ntia.doc.gov/comments/2008/ICANN_081218.pdf. Take a look at PAGE 1 of that PDF!! Where is the work about whether the domain registration market is one market or separate markets? Where is the work about substitutability? Where is the work about switching costs? And so on? Is ICANN trying to pull a fast one on the public, by not even instructing its paid consultants to do the right study?? Everyone should read the ENTIRE PDF from 2008. It was very detailed. Everyone should read the original comments to the Carlton reports and to the Phase I report (not the staff summaries). There were detailed submissions, and once again ICANN and its paid consultants have failed ..."--George Kirikos (emphasis added)
ICANN.org | Archives | New gTLD Program: Materials on TLD Demand and Economic Analysis:
- New gTLDs – Final Reports Available on Competition and Pricing [Broken Link on ICANN.org] (6 June 2009)
- Report Of Dennis Carlton Regarding ICANN's Proposed Mechanism for Introducing New gTLDs [PDF, 628K]
- Comments on Michael Kende's Assessment of Preliminary Reports on Competition and Pricing [PDF, 52K]
- New gTLDs – Preliminary Reports on Competition and Pricing (4 March 2009)
- Preliminary Report of Dennis Carlton Regarding Impact of New gTLDs on Consumer Welfare [PDF, 157K]
- Preliminary Analysis of Dennis Carlton Regarding Price Caps for New gTLD Internet Registries [PDF, 56K]
- Public Comment: CRAI Report on gTLD Registries and Registrars (24 October 2008)
- Report from CRA International “Revisiting Vertical Separation of Registries and Registrars” [PDF, 493K]
- According to the Best Available Data » Blog Archive » att/t-mobile and icann share economic consultants | blog.caida.org: "... But equally eye-opening is the economic consulting firm AT&T is using — the same one ICANN used to “study” whether gTLD expansion would benefit consumers. Unlike this transcript, that study I was actually allowed to read, so I and many others learned how dishonest it was. It is not clear who will learn about “certain economic issues of AT&T’s proposed acquisition of T-Mobile”…"
- According to the Best Available Data » Blog Archive » thoughts on ICANN’s plans to expand the DNS root zone by orders of magnitude | blog.caida.org
Other Internet Domain News:
• ICANN at 3rd World Internet Conference. Wuzhen, China | ICANN.org: "... heading to Wuzhen this week, together with two of our APAC Board members, Asha Hemrajani and Akinori Maemura, to attend the 3rd World Internet Conference held in my home country, China from 16 – 18 November."--Song Zheng, Head of China, ICANN. Remember last year, when then ICANN CEO Fadi Chehade went to Wuzhen for the World Internet Conference? See After Wuzhen, Should ICANN President & CEO Fadi Chehade Be Fired? | DomainMondo.com (28 December 2015).
Wuzhen Report on World Internet Development 2016 released | wuzhenwic.org: "President Xi Jinping addressed the gathering via video, and Mr. Liu Yunshan, Member of Standing Committee of Political Bureau of CPC Central Committee, delivered a keynote presentation at the opening ceremony. Over 1600 representatives from more than 110 countries and territories, and 16 international organizationshad a chance for extensiveand unrestricted discussions on Internet development prospects."
China Presses Tech Firms to Police the Internet | WSJ.com: "Alibaba now has about 3,000 of its nearly 50,000 employees involved in counterterrorism and cybersecurity efforts ... The main speaker at the conference wasn't a technology official, but the Chinese Communist Party’s ideological chief Liu Yunshan. Mr. Liu proclaimed China to be a global opinion leader on the use of new technologies in counterterrorism ... Many industry stakeholders aren't convinced. But the presence of big western companies at the conference -- including Facebook, International Business Machines Corp., Qualcomm Inc., Microsoft Corp. and LinkedIn Corp. -- illustrated the importance of China to their businesses."
• China’s vast Internet prison | WashingtonPost.com: "The latest effort came Monday. China’s national parliament approved a cybersecurity law that can be used to restrict free speech and force foreign Internet companies to heed the demands of China’s security services. Censorship is not new in China; a huge phalanx of officials are devoted to it, harsh punishments are meted out, and the country is ringed by a content-blocking Great Firewall. But now censorship will be more fully enshrined in the legal code." See also: China adopts new cybersecurity law that has overseas rights groups and businesses completely spooked: Shanghaiist.com: "Despite widespread international concern from corporations and rights advocates for more than a year, Chinese authorities pressed ahead with this restrictive law without making meaningful changes," said Human Rights Watch (HRW) China director Sophie Richardson.
• Freedom on the Net 2016 | FreedomHouse.org "Internet freedom around the world declined in 2016 for the sixth consecutive year.
- Two-thirds of all internet users – 67 percent – live in countries where criticism of the government, military, or ruling family are subject to censorship.
- Social media users face unprecedented penalties, as authorities in 38 countries made arrests based on social media posts over the past year. Globally, 27 percent of all internet users live in countries where people have been arrested for publishing, sharing, or merely “liking” content on Facebook.
- Governments are increasingly going after messaging apps like WhatsApp and Telegram, which can spread information quickly and securely."
• Correspondence | ICANN.org:
- 15 November 2016 Letter from Arif H. Ali, Dechert LLP to ICANN Board (pdf) published by ICANN 16 November 2016; Council of Europe Report DGI (2016)17 - re: new gTLD .GAY.
- 31 October 2016 Letter from Göran Marby to Mr. Houlin Zhao, Secretary General, International Telecommunication Union (ITU) [Published 06 November 2016] WTSA 2016 – Proposed AFCP Res: 47 about country code top-level domains (ccTLDs) and geographic domain names.
• CCWG ploughs on with WS2: ICANN57 | legallyindia.com: "substantial discussions in WS2 are only just kicking off, with some subgroups (such as the Diversity subgroup) yet to begin their deliberations"--for more on WS2 see WS2 - Enhancing ICANN Accountability | ICANN.org.
• WIPO Transparency: WIPO Adopts Open Access Policy for its Publications | WIPO.int: The World Intellectual Property Organization announced its new Open Access policy to promote the widest possible public access to its publications, furthering the Organization’s commitment to the dissemination and sharing of knowledge.
- News Review [5Nov]: ICANN57 Hyderabad, India, the Elephant in the Room
- What Your Wireless Carrier May Not Be Telling You, U.S. Mobile Data Usage
- .AFRICA, .WEB, ICANN Litigation Update, IRP & CEP Status Report
- TechReView [12Nov]: US Votes For Change, Silicon Valley Shell-Shocked (video)